Jump to content
Guest Preet_KaurG

Challenge of a Hindu

Recommended Posts

Guest Preet_KaurG

WGKWGF

After reading a BBC article on Hinduism, me and my Hindu work colleague were discussing idol worship. I was saying, how could an idol, something made of stone or clay, do any good to anyone? Isn't that wrong? He responded, "if idol worship is wrong than Guru Granth Sahib Ji is worng, because Guru Granth was written by a man, called Bhagath Dhann Jat, who worshiped idol and stones just like Hindus"!? I told him, i would become a Hindu if it's true! Than he showed me how Bhaai Gurdas wrote in his Vaars about the Bhagath who actually did worship stones and made offerings! 

What do i do?? How do i respond?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Guest Preet_KaurG said:

WGKWGF

After reading a BBC article on Hinduism, me and my Hindu work colleague were discussing idol worship. I was saying, how could an idol, something made of stone or clay, do any good to anyone? Isn't that wrong? He responded, "if idol worship is wrong than Guru Granth Sahib Ji is worng, because Guru Granth was written by a man, called Bhagath Dhann Jat, who worshiped idol and stones just like Hindus"!? I told him, i would become a Hindu if it's true! Than he showed me how Bhaai Gurdas wrote in his Vaars about the Bhagath who actually did worship stones and made offerings! 

What do i do?? How do i respond?

That in itself is false, Bhagat Dhanna Ji did worship Idols at one point but that was due to being mislead by a Pandit. God appeared to him due to his innocence, he also showed Bhagat Ji how in past lives he did so much Tapisya and Naam Simran, hence why God came to him. The minute God told him to stop and start doing Simran he abandoned it all. He was staunchly against it once he realised what was true. Why would you hold the actions of an innocent man who knew nothing but trusted the only authority in religion he had at the time (the pandit)

I'm well aware this is nothing more than a troll post but I still find it amusing how they try the most silliest of tactics. 

Reminds me of a Sakhi I heard a while back.

Quote

    

In the beautiful hills of the Punjab there was a fine temple of the goddess of power. In it stood a statue of the goddess. Every year thousands of people visited this temple and worshipped her. A fair was held every year to pay homage to the goddess. People from all over India came to this temple to worship during the fair. Even some Rajahs (Rulers) from the Hills attended the fair. The Rajahs usually brought money and rich offerings for the goddess. These offerings were collected by cunning priests who spent them lavishly for their personal enjoyment and not for the common good.

Sri Guru Har Gobind Sahib Ji Maharaj and his Sikhs went to one such fair to preach the Guru's way. The fair was in full swing. The Guru's Darbar (Holy Congregation) was on one side of the fair in an open space. The musicians were singing hymns in praise of God. They sang Shabads (Holy verses) from the Holy Granth. The soul-stirring hymns touched everybody's heart. People were attracted to the Guru's camp in such great numbers that only a few were left in the temple. Even the Rajahs came down to listen to the Guru's teachings.

Finding only a few people in the temple, a man named Bharu entered and pushed his way towards the idol. He struck the idol's nose with something hard and broke it off. Before the priests could catch him, the man ran out of the temple towards the Guru's Darbar. There was a sudden noise and people were running towards the Darbar after Bharu. A strong man from the Guru's Darbar stood up and caught him. People thought that he was a thief. In a few minutes, the priests also arrived and Bharu was presented to a Rajah sitting there in the Guru's court. The priest told the whole story to the Guru, the Rajah, and all the people who had gathered there. On hearing about the damage to the idol, the Rajah was so furious that he did not even listen to Bharu's side of the story and he ordered him to be stoned to death. The people took hold of the culprit and tried to drag him away but the Guru intervened and said, "It is better that we should listen to both sides of the story and then see if the man really deserves this punishment." The Guru thereupon asked both men to tell the truth. The priest spoke first :

Priest: This man is a great sinner; he has broken the nose of the goddess and he really deserves to be stoned to death.

Bhai Bharu: This is wrong. I haven't committed any Crime.

Priest: It is a crime to break the idol, isn't it?

Bhai Bharu: I don't know who you are and I haven't done any wrong to you. If I smashed the idol it is an affair between me and the idol. Let the idol say what it likes.

Priest: The idol is made of stone, how can it speak? If it were alive it would have caught and punished you there and then.

Bhai Bharu: If it cannot speak or defend itself, how can it speak to you and save the people or give them what they want? My sin is no worse than breaking the handle of a tea cup.

At this the priest could not say anything. Bhai Bharu's words made the people laugh and they really understood the idea behind what he said. Sri Guru Har Gobind Sahib Ji Maharaj, however, did not like all this and spoke out kindly, "Listen my friends," he said, "It is really no good worshipping idols. Man should worship God who has made living idols like us. But breaking an idol is not good. We must have respect and regard for other people's religion and way of worship. Breaking an idol with hatred is like breaking a heart, and the heart is the house of God. So by smashing the idol Bharu has sinned against God. He must apologise for what he has done and repair the idol."

Bhai Bharu was convinced of the Guru's point of view and asked to be pardoned. The people agreed to forgive him on condition that he never broke an idol again. Bhai Bharu gave his word and also repaired the broken idol. Very soon afterwards he became the Sikh of Sri Guru Har Gobind Sahib Ji Maharaj.

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Excellent sakhi. If you don't know who wrote the Guru Granth Sahib and what its message is - then please don't bother identifying yourself as  a sikh!!!! 

Why? Because you don't even know your Guru. So whose Sikh are you? 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Preet_KaurG

Why do trolls come to Sikhi forums, I will never ever know!! But the it's a genuine question, regarding the idolatry of Bhgath Dhaana Jat. According to Bhaai Gurdass, he performed idol worship, and even offered food (bread and buttermilk), but instead of rebuked by Waheguru, He actually accepted that particular form of worship and came down and ate food with Bhagat Dhanna Jat! Bit confused.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your content will need to be approved by a moderator

Guest
You are commenting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoticons maximum are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×