Jump to content
MrDoaba

So I took a Ethnicity DNA Test...

Recommended Posts

After waiting ages to take a DNA test, I finally got around to it recently. The results were, for the most part, what I expected.

Here's my estimate:

Asia - 85.4%

  • South Asian - 79.9%
  • West Asian (Iran, Afghanistan, Iraq, Caucasus, Turkey) - 4.3%
  • Central Asian (Afghanistan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Kazahkstan) - 1.4%

Europe - 14.6%

North and West Europe

  • Irish, Scottish, and Welsh - 11.6%
  • Scandinavian - 3.0%

Even though these are only estimates, they give an idea of my ethnicity in a broad sense. Nonetheless 14.6% is still considered a fairly large proportion in an estimate, and in all honesty was completely unexpected. My knowledge on DNA and genealogy are probably basic at best but from what I've read such a large percentage of the European could be traced back as early as the 5th or 6th generation before me!

This estimate didn't really tell me much as I would have liked to know so I decided to use GEDmatch to get a more in-depth picture. The results were certainly interesting (Jagsaw Singh if you're still around I'm sure you'll be the most pleased). For the sake of the topic I'll mention that I'm Punjabi Jatt.

This is what I found out:

Baloch - 37.94% (The term Baloch is used here to loosely describe Persian origin)

South Indian - 29.43% (South Indian here refers to indigenous or native Indian)

NE-Euro - 11.70% (oddly the Baltic region)

Caucasian  - 11.30% (Armenia, Georgia, Azerbaijan - again part of the Greater Persian Empire)

SW-Asian - 2.28% (ambiguously referring to Persian, Caucasian, and Arabian)

Mediterranean - 2.25% (most likely Greek, Cypriot, Turkish)

The rest is negligible.

You are also given an approximation how closely you are linked and compare to the individual populations of the sampling done by the genealogists, here are the top ten from highest to lowest:

1) Punjabi-Jatt-Sikh
2) Punjabi-Jatt-Muslim
3) Punjabi-Khatri
4) Pushtikar-Brahmin
5) Kashmiri-Pandit
6) Punjabi
7) Kashmiri
8) Punjabi-Brahmin
9) Rajasthani-Brahmin
10) Singapore-Indian

 

What do you think? I was surprised at some of the detail it went into and some of it was actually expected - I have always explained to people how we very likely had Persian and possibly some European ancestors. Although I probably won't, personally I would love to lay claim to my Persian heritage!

Has anybody here taken a test?

What labels, if any, do I use now...Persian Jatt  :rofl

I think the moral here is we shouldn't be so narrow-minded.

 

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Kira said:

 

LOL yeah yeah I took the generic one with a pinch of salt. The second one defo provides some insight though, if it's your kind of thing.

I'm an undercover RSS agent...see how closely I'm related to Brahmins.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ha ya Welsh sheep sha... 

That's crazy man. Could you share the link of the test you took? I'd like to give it a go

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, S4NGH said:

Ha ya Welsh sheep sha... 

That's crazy man. Could you share the link of the test you took? I'd like to give it a go

Oye saala.

I took mine with MyHeritage. There's quite a few companies which do it but no point wasting money on the more expensive generic ones. Once you get your results make sure you use GEDmatch after for better results - it's free.

https://www.myheritage.com/login?destination_url=https%3A%2F%2F

  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, AjeetSinghPunjabi said:

sorry to burst your bubble but such tests are mostly hyped 

https://www.livescience.com/7384-genetic-ancestry-tests-hype-scientists.html

Mate I do not fall for marketing so easily, and so naturally I did some reading before taking the test, and took it with a good dose of scepticism. I also took into account the companies' policy and disclaimer as well as general info on generic DNA testing, hence, my earlier comment about taking it with a pinch of salt. The link you provided is about 10 years old and DNA testing has come a long way since then, and unlike that article say, the test I took (like most generic companies today) looks at DNA from both the paternal and maternal line - which in most cases can only look at the last few hundred years or so. Still I see your point, it was quite vague and probabaly not as highly accurate as many would like it to be, then again they make it very clear that it's an estimate and that it gives you a rounded idea so it's not a wild guess either.

This is why I used GEDmatch - a free website created by professional genealogists with more utilities than aam janta would need. It's a no-frills site for people who are serious about genetics and genealogy and goes a bit further back to look for specific genetic markers. In order to use the site you only need your raw DNA data from the generic testing companies. The heritage/ethnicity tool they provide uses a large independent sample database which has calculators for specific reference populations which can pinpoint fairly well in my experience - this is evident from the fact that it picked up my Punjabi Jatt heritage. They've obviously done their work and I have no reason to dismiss the project, especially the one used for people with Asian origins.

All in all, there's nothing which is unusually surprising from my results - they seem to make the most logical sense according to history and geography. It's also worth mentioning that on both my paternal and maternal side, my grandparents, great grandparents, 2/3x great grandparents, great uncles and aunts had traits that tie in with my results - majority of them were very fair skinned, had light coloured eyes etc.

Up to you if you want to take them into consideration as an estimate, the second being rather accurate, or if you want to write the whole thing off as bullsh!t. We're all entitled to our opinions.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, MrDoaba said:

Mate I do not fall for marketing so easily, and so naturally I did some reading before taking the test, and took it with a good dose of scepticism. I also took into account the companies' policy and disclaimer as well as general info on generic DNA testing, hence, my earlier comment about taking it with a pinch of salt. The link you provided is about 10 years old and DNA testing has come a long way since then, and unlike that article say, the test I took (like most generic companies today) looks at DNA from both the paternal and maternal line - which in most cases can only look at the last few hundred years or so. Still I see your point, it was quite vague and probabaly not as highly accurate as many would like it to be, then again they make it very clear that it's an estimate and that it gives you a rounded idea so it's not a wild guess either.

This is why I used GEDmatch - a free website created by professional genealogists with more utilities than aam janta would need. It's a no-frills site for people who are serious about genetics and genealogy and goes a bit further back to look for specific genetic markers. In order to use the site you only need your raw DNA data from the generic testing companies. The heritage/ethnicity tool they provide uses a large independent sample database which has calculators for specific reference populations which can pinpoint fairly well in my experience - this is evident from the fact that it picked up my Punjabi Jatt heritage. They've obviously done their work and I have no reason to dismiss the project, especially the one used for people with Asian origins.

All in all, there's nothing which is unusually surprising from my results - they seem to make the most logical sense according to history and geography. It's also worth mentioning that on both my paternal and maternal side, my grandparents, great grandparents, 2/3x great grandparents, great uncles and aunts had traits that tie in with my results - majority of them were very fair skinned, had light coloured eyes etc.

Up to you if you want to take them into consideration as an estimate, the second being rather accurate, or if you want to write the whole thing off as bullsh!t. We're all entitled to our opinions.

 

tell me just one simple thing .

How does it change your life or kaum by knowing where you originated from ? It can only help one's ego to know that they're 15% european or .. you know .... a part of so called "elite"  race 

Edited by AjeetSinghPunjabi
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think it matters where you come from, to be honest. 

Does it affect your Sikhi, even in the slightest way?

If you are just doing it to find your history (somehow), then go ahead.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, monatosingh said:

I don't think it matters where you come from, to be honest. 

Does it affect your Sikhi, even in the slightest way?

If you are just doing it to find your history (somehow), then go ahead.

 

we all originated in africa . 

No rudeness intended to OP but honestly we're faced with so many dire issues in kaum that needs our immediate attention :/ 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, AjeetSinghPunjabi said:

tell me just one simple thing .

How does it change your life or kaum by knowing where you originated from ? It can only help one's ego to know that they're 15% european or .. you know .... a part of so called "elite"  race 

It doesn't, that's not why I took the test. I did it out of sheer curiosity, it's human nature to want to know your origins, and kade kade shaunk vi pura karna penda ah, no? It's had absolutely no impact on my life and it's not gonna. If the scientific side has no significance to you, then just see it as a bit of fun.

And no where in my post indicates I have an inflated ego brother, did you not read the Jatt joke? If any anything I put my results here in opposition to those who act elitist - infact some people I've mentioned the test to are scared to even entertain the idea of taking it, they're so fragile.

We are who we are and obviously it's not going to change.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, MrDoaba said:

It doesn't, that's not why I took the test. I did it out of sheer curiosity, it's human nature to want to know your origins, and kade kade shaunk vi pura karna penda ah, no? It's had absolutely no impact on my life and it's not gonna. If the scientific side has no significance to you, then just see it as a bit of fun.

And no where in my post indicates I have an inflated ego brother, did you not read the Jatt joke? If any anything I put my results here in opposition to those who act elitist - infact some people I've mentioned the test to are scared to even entertain the idea of taking it, they're so fragile.

We are who we are and obviously it's not going to change.

ok lol 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, AjeetSinghPunjabi said:

tell me just one simple thing .

How does it change your life or kaum by knowing where you originated from ? It can only help one's ego to know that they're 15% european or .. you know .... a part of so called "elite"  race 

I don't know man. If my results showed I was somehow any percentage european/white, I'd be pretty blumin disappointed... 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, S4NGH said:

I don't know man. If my results showed I was somehow any percentage european/white, I'd be pretty blumin disappointed... 

I don't even need a genetic test . I have golden brownish hair (esp near the skin) , brown eyes and fair skin , A positive blood group , 

My mother's side blue / light colored eyes not uncommon . All these traits point to some degree of european ancestry 

Anyways, we all have aryan blood . Aryans were nothing but central asians or europeans . 

Anyways why the eff does it matter lol 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, S4NGH said:

I don't know man. If my results showed I was somehow any percentage european/white, I'd be pretty blumin disappointed... 

To be fair if the Celtic part of the results are true, it's not as bad as it coming back British (even though you can't really define British). It's most likely to be Scottish as the Scots and Scandinavians did a fair bit of mingling.

Scottish people are quite admirable. At least in this regard:

"...for, as long as but a hundred of us remain alive, never will we on any conditions be brought under English rule. It is in truth not for glory, nor riches, nor honours that we are fighting, but for freedom – for that alone, which no honest man gives up but with life itself."

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • When God created the sirgun form as written in Japji Sahib then humans were born and lost in maya they keep reincarnation 
    •   A TRIBUTE TO DAUGHTERS   Daughter is not equal to tension
      But
      In today's world
      Daughter is equal to
      Ten son' s
      🙍👭🙍👭 A FATHER Asked His DAUGHTER:
      Who Would U Love More, Me Or Ur Husband..??
      👭👭🙍🙍👭👭🙍🙍 The BEST Reply Given By the DAUGHTER:
      I Don't Know Really,
      But When I See U,
      I Forget Him,
      But When I See Him,
      I Remember U..
      🙍🙍🙍👭👭👭👭🙍🙍🙍 U Can Always Call Ur DAUGHTER As Beta,
      But U Can Never Call Ur Son As Beti.. That's Why DAUGHTERS are SPECIAL
      👭🙍👭🙍👭👍👭👍👭🙍
      If you have a daughter who makes your life worth living by just being around and you love her as much as your own Breath..;
      🙍👭🙍👭🙍👭 If you are proud of your Daughter, send this to people who have daughters..!! Daughters are happiness.
      Daughters are angels.!👼👼 🙍👭👭👭👭👭👭🙍
          

      Congrats  to who all have daughters
      Daughters are like Parrots in the house.. When she speaks,
      Speaks without a break..
      & everyone says,
      "Will you please keep quite for sometime" When she is silent,
      mother says,
      Are you fine my child " Father says,
      "Why there is so much of silence " Brother says,
      "Are you angry with me ?" and when she is married, all says,
      "Its like all the happiness has gone from the house " She is the real non stop music.. Dedicated to emotional, cute, pretty, sweet & sincere girls😊
      That's You..
      That's a Girl..😊
      👌🍃Woman has the most unique character like salt
      Her presence is never remembered...but
      Her absence makes all the things tasteless !!🐾👍
      👌👍👯💃👯👭
      pass it to your lovely sisters, daughters and friends😊.                       To all the females in this world.
    •   NEVER CRY FOR THE PERSON WHO HURTS YOU JUST SMILE AND SAY THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME A CHANCE TO FIND SOMEONE BETTER THAN YOU   NEVER HATE JEALOUS PEOPLE THEY ARE JEALOUS, FOR THEY THINK  YOU ARE BETTER THAN THEM   DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME ON REVENGE THOSE WHO HURT YOU WILL EVENTUALLY  FACE THEIR OWN KARMA   NEVER TELL ANYONE YOUR PLANS SHOW THEM YOUR RESULTS   ONE GREAT LESSON I LEARNED FROM MY LIFE THERE IS NO MARKET FOR YOUR EMOTIONS SO NEVER ADVERTISE YOUR FEELINGS JUST SHOW YOUR ATTITUDE   DO NOT GIVE UP YOUR DAY WILL COME IT IS JUST A MATTER OF TIME   IF YOU ARE HELPING SOMEONE AND EXPECT SOMETHING IN RETURN YOU ARE DOING BUSINESS NOT KINDNESS   TRUST MEANS EVERYTHING ONCE IT IS  BROKEN SORRY MEANS NOTHING   ALWAYS REMEMBER YOUR PRESENT SITUATION IS NOT YOUR FINAL DESTINATION THE BEST IS YET TO COME   NEVER LEAVE A TRUE RELATION FOR A FEW FAULTS NOBODY IS CORRECT AT THE END AFFECTION IS ALWAYS GREATER THAN PERFECTION   DO NOT COME TO MY FUNERAL TO SHOW HOW MUCH YOU CARED ABOUT ME SHOW HOW MUCH YOU CARE ABOUT ME NOW WHILE I AM ALIVE   NEVER REPLAY WHEN YOU ARE ANGRY NEVER MAKE A PROMISE WHEN YOU ARE HAPPY NEVER MAKE A DECISION WHEN YOU ARE SAD   STOP EXPECTING LOYALTY FROM PEOPLE WHO CAN NOT EVEN GIVE YOU HONESTY   LIFE IS SHORT, TIME IS FAST NO REPLAY,  NO REWIND SO ENJOY EVERY MOMENT AS IT COMES   DO NOT GIVE UP THE BEGINNING IS  ALWAYS THE HARDEST   WHEN YOU WISH GOOD FOR OTHERS GOOD THINGS COME BACK TO YOU THIS IS THE LAW OF NATURE   DIFFICULTIES IN YOUR LIFE DO NOT COME TO DESTROY YOU BUT TO HELP YOU TO REALIZE YOUR HIDDEN POTENTIAL AND POWER   TURN YOUR ANGER INTO MOTIVATION AND YOUR MOTIVATION INTO SUCCESS.  
    • Ok lets reverse the relation , Daughter of some singh married into a Family of Hindu pandits ,but husband died , went to Pakistan and converted to islam.In that case would you have accepted her as Sikh?   The fact is she is daughter in law of Granthi so most probably she converted to Sikhism at the time of marriage.Now when she got widowed with three kids she had hardly any personal life left.Moreover I don't think his father  or Father in law thought of her re marriage.TBH there are hardly any sikh or Hindu men that marry a widow who is mother of three.So she may had found a Pakistani who was willing to accept her.Moreover she may had thought that she changed her religion for first marriage what's wrong if she did it for second time
    • Not sure on that, it's most likely out of our knowing until we merge with Waheguru.
×