Jump to content
proactive

Independent Newspaper's hit piece on Sikh Youth UK

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, Sukhvirk1976 said:

Please provide me with some evidence of this increase 

 

Syuk don't speak out against all terrorism or all discrimination.. They had nothing to say when 'Right wing', edl, Britain first nazi follower killed Jo Cox.. I don't see them and have not seen them speaking out against attacks on minorities in the wake of brexit.. The fact is they choose to homogenise a very diverse community of people and demonise a entire religious group which is ridiculous.. 

 

How ironic that you see a group like syuk as opposing intolerance.. The mind boggles at the intellectual  gymnastics your able to make.. 

I have no problem in opposing any bigotry.. And will always stand against intolerance however that doesn't mean I will demonise a diverse group of people who come under a lazy umbrella term.. There are many different voices of Islam, sunni, Shia, ahmadi, sufi... Just in the same way sikh panth is plural and made up of people who have commonalities but also are very different.. 

You seem confused and conflate, Marxism, communism, and socialism.. 

Marxism is a theory about the nature of the  economic organisation of society and the implications of that.. I'm not a marxist or a communist... However I think sikh philosophy is largely congruent with much of the social aspects of it 

You have given your whole game away.

You've provided exactly what I said you were.

I have given ample examples, yet you come back with more questions.

Which means my assessment was correct.

You'll come back I'm sure with asking of an example of the example I have provided.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Ranjeet01 said:

You have given your whole game away.

You've provided exactly what I said you were.

I have given ample examples, yet you come back with more questions.

Which means my assessment was correct.

You'll come back I'm sure with asking of an example of the example I have provided.

What game? Lol 

  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Ranjeet01 said:

You have given your whole game away.

You've provided exactly what I said you were.

I have given ample examples, yet you come back with more questions.

Which means my assessment was correct.

You'll come back I'm sure with asking of an example of the example I have provided.

You haven't actually given me your definition of what a cultural marxist is and how you have discerned that I am one.. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Sukhvirk1976 said:

Oh dear.. 

Just to clarify are you suggesting sikhi does not promote egalitarianism? Seriously.. 

Iv asked you to show me it from 18/19th century sources.

I'm sure you can mange that, I've not made any assertations here about what Sikhi promotes, you have so back it up. You whine  about wanting evidence from others so follow your own wants, I wait with eager breath of your your sources, your own hand drawn translations abd so on.

 

How would you know what it promotes. You can't even read the source material so who told you it did? 😂 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, Kira said:

Iv asked you to show me it from 18/19th century sources.

I'm sure you can mange that, I've not made any assertations here about what Sikhi promotes, you have so back it up. You whine  about wanting evidence from others so follow your own wants, I wait with eager breath of your your sources, your own hand drawn translations abd so on.

 

How would you know what it promotes. You can't even read the source material so who told you it did? 😂 

Ek onkaar

  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sikh Press Association, Sikh Council UK and Sikh Youth UK have issued a press release and response to the independents article.

Note how it highlights the grass roots work SYUK carry out in the community directly with families , councils and the police. Note to mention the awards they have won. What community work do the Sunny Hundal, Katy Sian, Rana crew actually do ? What is their contribution to the mission of and ethos of Sikhi ???

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Cisco_Singh said:

Sikh Press Association, Sikh Council UK and Sikh Youth UK have issued a press release and response to the independents article.

Note how it highlights the grass roots work SYUK carry out in the community directly with families , councils and the police. Note to mention the awards they have won. What community work do the Sunny Hundal, Katy Sian, Rana crew actually do ? What is their contribution to the mission of and ethos of Sikhi ???

 

 

Hundal, Sian do lots of community work.

Just guess which community they work for.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Sukhvirk1976 said:

Ek onkaar

So you have no references to any historical documentations, thank you for showing everyone you simply talk out of your rear end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Cisco_Singh said:

Sikh Press Association, Sikh Council UK and Sikh Youth UK have issued a press release and response to the independents article.

Note how it highlights the grass roots work SYUK carry out in the community directly with families , councils and the police. Note to mention the awards they have won. What community work do the Sunny Hundal, Katy Sian, Rana crew actually do ? What is their contribution to the mission of and ethos of Sikhi ???

 

 

They are big contributors to the "find new things to get offended at" brigade. 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
56 minutes ago, Kira said:

So you have no references to any historical documentations, thank you for showing everyone you simply talk out of your rear end.

I thought you read sggsj? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
53 minutes ago, Sukhvirk1976 said:

I thought you read sggsj? 

Yes I do, but that's not an argument. So please find historical documentation and proof, unless now you'll argue that sikhs in the past were fools who didn't understand Sikhi at all. I'm waiting for that curcial evidence you love to ask for but never give, I can use your daft argument for anything.

"Hey I robbed a bank, its ok cuz Ek Onkar" "hey some woman got raped, its ok Ek Onkar. "

 

So i'm repeating once again, find HISTORICAL documentation from Purtan sources that prove your stance. If you're incapable of that then I rest my case, you're nothing more than a dog barking .

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

guess it's open seaon on sikhs now , rehashing old BS to start another round of justification for labelling and interfering, BTW sukhvirk learn to stand up for your kaum first because they are the only ones who will have your back - no other people

http://www.thehindu.com/news/international/reaching-out-to-britains-sikh-community/article19896728.ece

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • What about Gurbani? I never said we should change Gurbani, because we can’t. But we can remove Perso-Arabic influences from our vernacular.  And when did I say that we should all begin to speak Hindi and Sanskrit, no that’s a terrible idea. We need to revise Punjabi, and you can call me whatever you like, but I firmly stand by that. Have you forgotten that the very tyrants that killed our Gurus, the Sahibzaades, slaughtered our men, our women, and children, sold our ancestors as slaves, pillaged our land for centuries imposed Perso-Arabic influences onto our language. If we have any ounce of self respect, we should purge those influences from our language.  How am I demoting Punjabi? How am I saying we should stray away from Gurmukhi? In fact if you read any of my other threads you will realize I advocate further development of Gurmukhi and Punjabi. Why are you accusing me of things that I am opposed against in the first place?
    • The Saroop is only similar externally, ideologically there is a world of difference: https://tisarpanthdotcom.wordpress.com/2017/04/01/panj/
    • I began to realize, albeit a bit too late, that there really wasn’t any point in arguing with Jagsaw any further. But I gave the poster some benefit of doubt. But thank you for reassuring me that I wasn’t wrong in my judgment.
    • Kick out Gurwant from the Gurdwara. Do this to every Indian politician unless they prove they deserve otherwise. But for pete's sake what is "ehdi shame shame kro," have a discussion with him, and make him reveal his true colours. 
    • ok duniya for example was used in Gurbani so what then ?...I think Punjabi was selected as it has elements of all parts of society represented and is lok boli ...Tej seems to want to turn revisionist  as the deluded hinduvta folks are doing  ...surely as Sikhs we can be evenhanded and preserve our maa boli without chopping it up into shreds. It is not a major thing if we say odd words here and there , I mean if you were so incensed by the historical insults of mughals then what would you do about hindi /sanskrit as the pushers of those cultural languages have attacked Harmandir Sahib Four times in 70 years, reneged on promises, stolen water, dishonoured our womenfolk and murdered our men ? And now try to demote your language and its Guru-given script as secondary to Thug's languages  
×