Jump to content
Big_Tera

Sikh eating beef

Recommended Posts

acsap    258
1 minute ago, ipledgeblue said:

ok but you said all meats are the same, and this is the argument most ignorant sikhs use when they don't care whether we eat halal or not. please be a bit more clear next time.

I see your point. I meant all animals that people eat. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Not2Cool2Argue    346
59 minutes ago, acsap said:

I see your point. I meant all animals that people eat. 

I dont think so. I think sikhs in the past and now refrain from killing and eating cows. But I dont know our position on eating pigs or pork. It seems that asking fellow sikhs to eat pork was a way to test for muslim spys as can be seen when bandayi khalsa was reunited with tatt khalsa. 

One reason we dont eat beef is the same reason jews people dont mix dairy and meat. They dont want to boil the calf in its mom's milk. Meaning they dont want to be akirtghan. If you drink cow or buffalo milk, then you should not kill cows or buffalos. 

Sikhs kill goats but I dont know many sikhs who drank goat milk in the past, or anyone who drink it now in India. 

Also, if u are  a vegetarian, but u drink milk of an animal. You have to.make sure that in the process of getting that milk, no animal is harmed. Or you become a meat eater. That's the main reason, cows were not hurt in ancient india. Like vegans blame vegetarians today for consuming dairy which causes male offapring to be killed. This is a direct cause of you drinking milk so you will be held accountable for those deaths. Therefore, vegetarians have to make sure that the one animal whose animal products they use, is not harmed. Otherwise vegans are right and vegetarians are the most hypocritical ppl with the largest cause of meat slaughter.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ipledgeblue    73
7 hours ago, Not2Cool2Argue said:

I dont think so. I think sikhs in the past and now refrain from killing and eating cows. But I dont know our position on eating pigs or pork. It seems that asking fellow sikhs to eat pork was a way to test for muslim spys as can be seen when bandayi khalsa was reunited with tatt khalsa. 

I think the Singhs who hunted wild boar made it clear for pork. I mean the shingar on the dumalla for boar's horn should only be worn by actual Singhs who hunt boar, it is not something to be just bought and put in there. It is a soor-bir type of symbol.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jkvlondon    3,500
38 minutes ago, ipledgeblue said:

I think the Singhs who hunted wild boar made it clear for pork. I meant the shingar on the dumalla for boar's horn should only be worn by actual Singhs who hunt boar, it is not something to be just bought and put in there. It is a soor-bir type of symbol.

soor bir ? not from soor pig  but soorma brave ...please what you suggested makes it pig-warrior please think a little

Edited by jkvlondon
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ipledgeblue    73
13 hours ago, jkvlondon said:

soor bir ? not from soor pig  but soorma brave ...please what you suggested makes it pig-warrior please think a little

yeh I did mean it as a bravery thing. And I know it sounds similar. soorbir or soorvir (different ways to pronounce it)

Boars are dangerous animals. OF course, hunting lions and tigers is even more brave.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Destruction    155
16 hours ago, ipledgeblue said:

I think the Singhs who hunted wild boar made it clear for pork. I mean the shingar on the dumalla for boar's horn should only be worn by actual Singhs who hunt boar, it is not something to be just bought and put in there. It is a soor-bir type of symbol.

Most of these wanabe nihangs (who dress like nihangs) don't realise how hard it is to kill a wild boar with arrows/daggers/swords and even the gun! The way they charge at the hunter, they aren't small animals...some are huge X3 size of a person . Takes a lot of skill to kill one. Majority of those who keep a shingar is for fashion, heck they are even against chatka and are strict vegetarians. Quite ironic.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sikhiseeker    263

Again, puranatan sikh did hunt and consume meat agreed. However for today's sikhs my point is if your not prepared to kill the animal because for e.g you haven't got the heart. But your all at the ready to eat it, whether it's a chicken or a cow, then that's simply just a convenience for you within your diet.

You will only understand what it means to eat meat when you Jhatkaa the animal, skin it/de-feather it's carcass, gut it, butcher it and then cook it. This is when even the meat eater will become a vegetarian because it's this very process which has been removed making it so easy to consume a animal, removing the messy part. 

That's why there's no daya in mcdonalds or asda...etc meat products. 

If your Amritdhari sikh and want to eat meat, hunt or kill the animal yourself and perform jhatka.

 

 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jkvlondon    3,500
10 hours ago, sikhiseeker said:

Again, puranatan sikh did hunt and consume meat agreed. However for today's sikhs my point is if your not prepared to kill the animal because for e.g you haven't got the heart. But your all at the ready to eat it, whether it's a chicken or a cow, then that's simply just a convenience for you within your diet.

You will only understand what it means to eat meat when you Jhatkaa the animal, skin it/de-feather it's carcass, gut it, butcher it and then cook it. This is when even the meat eater will become a vegetarian because it's this very process which has been removed making it so easy to consume a animal, removing the messy part. 

That's why there's no daya in mcdonalds or asda...etc meat products. 

If your Amritdhari sikh and wahant to eat meat, hunt or kill the animal yourself and perform jhatka.

 

 

 

remember each maccie D burger has meat of average one hundred carcasses mixed together, imagine the karmic load of just that one burger ...would you for 'cardboard food'??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sikhiseeker    263
2 hours ago, jkvlondon said:

remember each maccie D burger has meat of average one hundred carcasses mixed together, imagine the karmic load of just that one burger ...would you for 'cardboard food'??

Penji I can't understand what you wrote, what was you saying about the cardboard box?

kinda gone over my head

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jkvlondon    3,500
1 hour ago, sikhiseeker said:

Penji I can't understand what you wrote, what was you saying about the cardboard box?

kinda gone over my head

 

 

 

Fake food as nutritious as cardboard thus cardboard food

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
InderjitS    994
On 17/07/2017 at 1:35 AM, Big_Tera said:

Its mostly jatts from what I have seen. My local mcdonalds if full of them, gorging on big macs and quarter pounders. absolute discrace then they go and drink a bottle of whisky dance around like some pendus and have the decency to think they ard better then everyone else. 

Is it stamped on their heads or do you have a specially designed nose to sense Jaat Paat?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Big_Tera    399
28 minutes ago, InderjitS said:

Is it stamped on their heads or do you have a specially designed nose to sense Jaat Paat?

You can usually tell

MV5BZDQyMWVkNjItZTE5ZC00ZmQ2LWFkMjUtODc0Y2M2NWI0NGNjXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMzY1MTkwMDM@._V1_UY268_CR9,0,182,268_AL_.jpg

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
simran345    2,456
1 hour ago, InderjitS said:

Is it stamped on their heads or do you have a specially designed nose to sense Jaat Paat?

Lol

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I suspect three faith who have a common creation story would have been a pointless exercise ...
    • Nice to see such great scholars we have...or should I say internet Gianni It was Sant Gurbachan Singh of Binderkala who FIRST said this about the Sahibzade and is available in his mp3 CDs I don't see why Ultra kattar illiterate tunnel vision Sikhs cannot see the relationship between devteh and Sikhism perhaps if you listened to all the CDS you would have some foundation knowledge such as Nanaksar Sarovar helped built by Devteh and Baoli Sahib Well connects to Ganges etc etc there are many proofs of this such as Bhagat being previously devteh BTW ALOT OF MODERN KATHA AND SAMPARDAI KATHA IS TAKEN FROM THE SANT GURBACHAN SINGH CDS
    • The UK is largely a post Christian society. The institution of religion has been broken down over the past few decades for the British whites.  How would you suggest that Gurdwaras adapt. Are Sangat attendances down? Gurudware are packed over the weekends (though this could be due to the akhand paths, sukhmani paths and Anand Karajs taking place)and with the numerous Gurpurabs, Band Chor Divas and Vaisakhi.   If you go to the Gurdwarae during the weekday, you'd be surprised how much Sangat there is at different times of the day. Our congregation operates very differently to the Judeo Christian one.
    • took me a while but I found the book and the passage.      Just remember that within Kaal Purkh (the lord) there are millions upon millions of Vishnus, Shivas, Brahmas, Indras and so on.
    • How can it cause further hatred?  In the several thousand mosques in the UK, there are thousands of speeches that denigrate the kafir way of live. Is that not denigrating? Does that not reinforce bad feelings towards the kafir in dar-ul-harb? Jews are called monkeys and pigs, yet does that not cause/re-in force against jews? If muslims do bad things disproportionately to the size of their population,  do we not have the right to call out the bad things? I do not think Sikhs will hate any further. All that I can see Sikhs is saying a collective "I told you so!" to the mainstream community.
×