Well at my amrit sanchar I was given it with Arril but not with all the chaupai's and dhora's.
I guess if the SGPC version is panth minimum then yes it's acceptable. As long as its still 5 baania and the minimum length then its still amrit
It's strange that they call themselves Ramgharia sikhs but do more tarkhan/lohaar/carpentar rituals.
Did Ramgharia misl actually do these rituals?
It's also strange that it's also "Ramgharia" sikhs easily recognizable with their surnames are the forefront of the "you shouldn't believe in caste" argument and yet they do all this caste and separate gurdwara stuff?
jatts had shrines too to ancestors if they can abandon those and remove them from their fields because they have gained gian from Guru ji why not others . It is not destroying anyone's culture just abandoning the emptiness for fruitful endeavours . Also if these people are so desperate why not take their pooja to a hindu temple . Since when is it acceptable for the court/residence of a king to be usurped for the praises of some other person ?? It's is a slippery slope which will end with Mahant's murtis and bhut being replaced in our Gurdwarey