WaheguruBlessYou

What is everyone's views on Kirtan Competitions?

5 posts in this topic

WJKK WJKF

The other week I came across a singing reality programme 'Gavo Sachi Bani' on PTC Channel. I love listening to Kirtan, so I enjoyed watching it and then it hit me.

It's a kirtan competition!!! Are our gursikhs doing Kirtan for the wrong reasons? Ego? Name? Status? 

I understand competitions/reality programmes may be used as a way to bring in the youth. There's a fine line.... But surely if we focus on educating humanity of the meaning and understanding of each shabad, wouldn't that itself bring in Sikh youth? 

As a person, I am very open minded and liberal. As a Sikh, I don't do our daily nitnem, a bit of naam simran here and there. I do try to focus on being humane... I have joined this forum, like yourselves to learn and educate myself. Maybe Satguru ji will bless me with the thirst of doing paath everyday...

Before I get carried away typing every thought... Back to topic, are we using Shabad Kirtan not as a method to unite us with akaal purak but making us slaves to our vices?!

Forgive me if I have said anything wrong. I'm here to learn. Students make mistakes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I sat in the gurdwara and the giani jis voice was hurting my ears, I had little choice but to leave.  

I looked around for someone to complain to but could not find anyone.  Competitions might help perfectify people.  Wgat better chance can anyone who lacks motivation for shabad reading get? 

Yes we need good kirtan going on in the guradwara not just some ear hurting noise.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, sikhni777 said:

When I sat in the gurdwara and the giani jis voice was hurting my ears, I had little choice but to leave.  

I looked around for someone to complain to but could not find anyone.  Competitions might help perfectify people.  Wgat better chance can anyone who lacks motivation for shabad reading get? 

Yes we need good kirtan going on in the guradwara not just some ear hurting noise.

Most likely the sound system. Sound settings are the worst in mostly all gurdwaras. Get together with few folks and buy a professional to help tweaking and buying new speakers. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My opinion is that there should not be Kirtan competitions , BUT a platform at the Gurudawara made available to anyone who is learning kirtan be they a beginner, intermediate or advanced level. Obviously not just turning up on the day , need to be practicing first. This way gives the student an incentive to learn and a sense of purpose knowing that they will be singing a shabad at their local / central gurudawara. I think this will develop their skills , make they want to learn more , build their confidence and hopefully continue singing shabads and move to the next level of vichaaring the shabad as well as singing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"The first kirtaniya going home tonight is..." *unnecessarily long and drawn out pause to exaggerate suspense for dramatic affect* "...Sukhjit Singh! Oh, didn't he do well? It was so close, but your vaja was out of tune."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Baba Farid never said that 
    • A true "Sikh" is one who believes in Gurbani wholeheartedly, They also believe Guru Nanak Dev Ji is the only ship that can save you in Kalyug. A true Muslim believes in the Quran and Muhammad wholeheartedly. Similar concepts for a Christian, so tell me how Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Muhammad and Jesus are all on the same level. If only Guru Nanak Dev Ji can save someone in kalyug these figures can't do anything. So uhm no, its impossible to be both.    Mool Mantar says "Gur prasad", with the Grace of the GURU. So tell me is Muhammad a Guru now? The only Guru who's existed throughout the ages and who exists for anyone in Kalyug is Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Rather than repeating the same trash again and again and again I thought it would be smart to ask you a straightforward question but it seems that has either exploded your mind or (judging by the fact you can't seem to formulate your thoughts into 1 post) you just wish to talk out of your rear end all the time. I'll ask you again.  A Muslim who proclaims Muhammad is the only way to God. How can he also proclaim that Gurbani is a viable Option. The very core of any muslim is the fact that they all recite that Muhammad is the only way to God. SO tell me how someone can say 2 polar opposites and also be both. How can someone call something a lie and the truth at the same time. Gurbani also states that the Quran, Vedas etc are all incomplete, How can someone sit there and say that but also say "the Quran is perfect" . Yeah no. Nice try. 
    • So you don't agree with mool mantar? 
    • Gurbani is unique and the message transcends dogmatism.. 
    • Someone who is a true Muslim, true Christian, true 'sikh' doesn't get lost in communalism