Sansahar Sukhmana

[shastarSingh]

Why this composition was deleted by the Sodhak Committee ? Does Budha Dal consider it to be Gurbani ?

thanks

[savinderpalsingh]

yes they do consider it, but no one listens to nihangs
This bani is also present in Sri Hazur sahib 10 granthi

[shastarSingh]

I have heard this bani praises Hindu deities and Vedas.

Vedas have been completely rejected in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.

[singh598]

I have heard this bani praises Hindu deities and Vedas.

Vedas have been completely rejected in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.

What do you mean by rejected - Guru Sahib would never say anything that would hurt the feelings of other religions hence - Bed Katebh Kaho Mat Chuteh, Chuta Jo Na Beechare

[Bijla Singh]

Please read Shabad 2 veechar here: searchsikhism.com/islam1

[Jonny101]

Please read Shabad 2 veechar here: searchsikhism.com/islam1

excellent arths.

[savinderpalsingh]

instead of blaming gurubani , have you ever thought there would be defect in your own budhi?

we cannot understand the bani and what do we do?

blame on the bani !!

good going

[Bijla Singh]

If your comment is directed to me then:

The same argument can be applied to you as well. Maybe your buddhi is defected for considering the wrong meanings.

Interpretation I provided is not only according to grammar but also in consonance with the rest of Gurbani. These meanings are not new nor invented by Singh Sabha. The translation is wrong because it throws the whole context of the pauri out of the flow. I did not blame Gurbani. I blame translation to be wrong.

[N30S1NGH]

I would rather listen interpretation of - Bed Katebh Kaho Mat Chuteh, Chuta Jo Na Beechare by sant gyani gurbachan singh khalsa bhindranwale as it flows with overall position of vedas held by gurbani than listening to reformist black and white abhramic interpretations..anyway we already been through this before...sikhi isn't some cheap insecure faith nor its like jevoh witness Christian missionary faith..!!

I put neo tat khalsa ideology same as rss, neo nazi, sharia fascist ideology...only difference is they aren't in power...once they are in power, its the same old bigotry crap with different face lift..!!

[Bijla Singh]

There you go with your cheap shots. For your ignorant brain, Singh Sabha was not a reform movement but a revival movement. This has been proven on academic level. Numerous books have been written on Singh Sabha yet I doubt you ever went beyond the literature published by Damdami Taksal. If Sikhi isn’t insecure then why are you so insecure about your personal beliefs? Why can’t you ever prove yourself right by providing proofs instead of attacking and belittling others? You seem to be stuck at the same point for the last 10 years. Calling anything wrong doesn’t make it wrong. Where’s the proof and what reasoning do you have to prove it wrong?

You have no idea what RSS, Fascist and Nazi ideology is all about yet a fool like you has the audacity to compare Sikhs with such infamous and notorious groups. I suggest you pick a dictionary first and read the definition. Is that all you have learned from sampardas and company of sant/mahapurash/brahmgyanis? I am willing to debate you on this anytime anywhere provided that you provide proofs and debate it with rules of logic rather than hold one person as “know-it-all” by elevating him to God’s level and consider him to be the only ultimate authority. Your own post and language used show how intolerant and insecure you are as well as being a bigot against others’ viewpoint. These are the elements of fascism.

I didn’t write a post to attack any personal, viewpoint or a jatha. You could’ve done the same but I guess sampardas are not teaching good virtues anymore and the only “logical” defense they have is to throw insults. When will you grow up?