do we know Lt .Gen Sinha who refused to take part in Ghallughara Bluestar

[Mehtab Singh]

[Singh559]

Yeah, I've seen his interviews. To this day he hasn't got a single promotion due to not part-taking in the genocide of the Sikhs.

Important lesson is if you want to be promoted in India, you should support the Sikh genocide or have some part in it.

[Mehtab Singh]

Actually he was ambassador to Nepal, governor of Assam, governor of Jammu & Kashmir.

[N30S1NGH]

Salute to Lt Gen Sinha...true warrior .!!

[Singh559]

I was told he had also written a book (actually written by him) about the incident. Would be nice to read.

[Singh559]

Who has won and who has lost?

Gen. Brar who is in his 70s and looks like his eyes will pop out of his head. He obviously has nightmares and relives that day day and day again and is scared for his life, but he got promoted and honored by India.

On the other hand General Sinha's jameer hadn't died and did not care for pleasing anyone but his own jameer and has his conscious clean to this day. 86 year old happy man. Respect.

[ghatak]

he knew that 1984 attack will only cause more hatred, nothing else

[khalistan_zindabaad]

This interview contains priceless information and should be put everywhere. Try wanted to attack Mehta chowk with tanks aswell, didn't know that and also his personal accounts are good.

[JasSinghKhalsa]

Just a minute, saw this video for 10 seconds, General Sinha says PM orders, can PM in India order on his/her own for an army attack, is Cabinet Approval not required? Was this done?

Is President approval (although superficial) not required, was this done?

[lsingh]

Indira was like a dictator, minister were like puppets,always ready to please her as was the President ,Zail Singh.

It makes it even more outstanding that General Sinha stood upto Indira. He sounds a bit like the Nawab of Malerkotla who advised the Mughal ruler against the execution of the Sahibzadas, whilst the Hindu Ministers were in favour of the Sahibzadas execution. You can put Brar and Dyal in their place.

Interesting that Gen Sunderji was so blinded in becoming a Field Marshal ( highest army position) he was willing do anything and led the attack, on his death bed Sinha states Sunderji was unable to speak or write. He gestured to his face , meaning beard , Sinha took this as a reference to Bluestar. A few hours later Sunderji was dead.

Interesting facts in this interview on how many plans were avaible to prevent bloodshed that should be publicised.