Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Singh123456777

Total Mockery Against Ragmalla!

Recommended Posts

http://gurmatbibek.c...ead.php?3,22532

These people are going way out of hand by disrespecting gurbani like this.They are against raag mala but going way out of hand by writing poems degrading it is really foolish.I can accept the fact that people don't believe in raag mala but disrespecting it is another story.

YOU GUYS CANNOT SILENCE ME!(maybe you guys can but i will keep on posting this topic till it will be discussed!)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok veer, relax!!!!!!

I did reply to your PM to me about this. I did raise my concern at the Gurmat Bibek forum as well and eventually the thread there was locked. I understand it can be offensive to GurSikhs, so I requested you to please contact the admins at Gurmat Bibek regarding this issue. Mai tuhanu kush galt keha si?

I promise you, we will not allow or tolerate any such disrespect here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I heard what you said but i did not like what the admins did.They are trying to be like syria by silencing there victims.

Thats the reason why i posted it again.

Dont worry mehtab singh i still your friend :lol2:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Singh12345678,

I don't think such dis-respect would be tolerated here as mehtab singh suggested. In fact, original poster on that website thread is either put on quality control or banned from sikhsangat..as far as i know by searching the archives..so its ok veer..thats glimpse of overzealous cultish chela for you..you will find quite bit of them in your life...its just human nature....its ok..lets all focus on ourselves ..!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't we respectfully disagree?

I believe in Raag Maala and have no reason to believe otherwise, but I don't think we should post such things that will cause further divisions. If people don't want to believe in Raag Malaa, if i'm not mistaken, it is their choice and I personally think they should be gupt about it and not create problems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hell yea

We are all united.

I have no problem with people who don't believe raag mala but someone insulting it is another story!

I know you still my phrend. I also jor phrend still.

Yes vee all phrends!

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't we respectfully disagree?

I believe in Raag Maala and have no reason to believe otherwise, but I don't think we should post such things that will cause further divisions. If people don't want to believe in Raag Malaa, if i'm not mistaken, it is their choice and I personally think they should be gupt about it and not create problems.

Hypocrisy...darsan lal is wrong for denying dasam bani...but if you reject sri raagmaala bani it seems to be ok and acceptable?..where is the logic in that?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hypocrisy...darsan lal is wrong for denying dasam bani...but if you reject sri raagmaala bani it seems to be ok and acceptable?..where is the logic in that?

I guess Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib are hypocrites.

Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib said darshan lal is tankhaiya and I'm pretty sure Akaal Takhat Sahib said it's up to the individual whether or not they want to read/believe in Raag Maala.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's important to post all sides of this issue if people want an open discussion. It's sad that I feel reluctant to post this because I know the reaction from many of the members as saying "these people were protestant or these people were this or these people were that".

Live and let live and stand only by Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib.

http://www.panthic.org/articles/5287

Iqbal Singh Edict labels Ramgala non-readers as great sinners and manmukh

In addition to making Ramgala obligatory, Giani Iqbal Singh’s edict also labeled those who do not recite it as “maha-paapi” (great sinners) and manmukhs.

In a telephone conversation with a Panthic.org correspondent Giani Iqbal Singh was asked whether he considered great Gurmukhs such as Maha-Kavi Santokh Singh, Giani Gian Singh, Giani Ditt Singh, Prof. Gurmukh Singh (founders of Singh Sabha Movement), Sant Teja Singh Manstuana, Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha, Bhai Randhir Singh Ji Narangwal, Prof. Sahib Singh, Bhai Randhir Singh Ji Research Scholar, Dr. Trilochan Singh, Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh, Shaheed Bhai Anokh Singh Babbar, Shaheed Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar and countless others who did not recite Ragmala as ‘maha-pappi’ or ‘manmukh’ ?

PanthicGurmukh_and_Shaheeds_NRM.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What proof does anybody have that maha kavi santhok singh didnt read raag mala?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's important to post all sides of this issue if people want an open discussion. It's sad that I feel reluctant to post this because I know the reaction from many of the members as saying "these people were protestant or these people were this or these people were that".

Live and let live and stand only by Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib.

http://www.panthic.org/articles/5287

[/size][/font][/color]

PanthicGurmukh_and_Shaheeds_NRM.jpg

What proof do you have that maha kavi santhok singh didnt read raag mala?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What proof does anybody have that maha kavi santhok singh didnt read raag mala?

Great, I'm a bit relieved that a question came out of my post. If we can't openly discuss such issues, we're bound to fail.

From what Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha wrote (source pathahi10) is that when Sri Dasam Granth Sahib was sent to Guru Ki Kaanshi Sri Damdama Sahib Talwandi Sabho there was a controversy whether or not Sri Dasam Granth Sahib was to be split or not into Pothian. Bhai Sukha Singh (I think dada ji of Rattan Singh Bhangu) said if I go and cut off the head of Massa Rangarh and come back alive this Granth will stay Sampooran and will not be changed at all. Everyone said satbachan and it happened and to this day Sri Dasam Granth Sahib is complete.

I'm assuming in Suraj Parkash it says that Kavi Santokh Singh Ji didn't read it, but I don't know the source myself, I will ask around...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • When God created the sirgun form as written in Japji Sahib then humans were born and lost in maya they keep reincarnation 
    •   A TRIBUTE TO DAUGHTERS   Daughter is not equal to tension
      But
      In today's world
      Daughter is equal to
      Ten son' s
      🙍👭🙍👭 A FATHER Asked His DAUGHTER:
      Who Would U Love More, Me Or Ur Husband..??
      👭👭🙍🙍👭👭🙍🙍 The BEST Reply Given By the DAUGHTER:
      I Don't Know Really,
      But When I See U,
      I Forget Him,
      But When I See Him,
      I Remember U..
      🙍🙍🙍👭👭👭👭🙍🙍🙍 U Can Always Call Ur DAUGHTER As Beta,
      But U Can Never Call Ur Son As Beti.. That's Why DAUGHTERS are SPECIAL
      👭🙍👭🙍👭👍👭👍👭🙍
      If you have a daughter who makes your life worth living by just being around and you love her as much as your own Breath..;
      🙍👭🙍👭🙍👭 If you are proud of your Daughter, send this to people who have daughters..!! Daughters are happiness.
      Daughters are angels.!👼👼 🙍👭👭👭👭👭👭🙍
          

      Congrats  to who all have daughters
      Daughters are like Parrots in the house.. When she speaks,
      Speaks without a break..
      & everyone says,
      "Will you please keep quite for sometime" When she is silent,
      mother says,
      Are you fine my child " Father says,
      "Why there is so much of silence " Brother says,
      "Are you angry with me ?" and when she is married, all says,
      "Its like all the happiness has gone from the house " She is the real non stop music.. Dedicated to emotional, cute, pretty, sweet & sincere girls😊
      That's You..
      That's a Girl..😊
      👌🍃Woman has the most unique character like salt
      Her presence is never remembered...but
      Her absence makes all the things tasteless !!🐾👍
      👌👍👯💃👯👭
      pass it to your lovely sisters, daughters and friends😊.                       To all the females in this world.
    •   NEVER CRY FOR THE PERSON WHO HURTS YOU JUST SMILE AND SAY THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME A CHANCE TO FIND SOMEONE BETTER THAN YOU   NEVER HATE JEALOUS PEOPLE THEY ARE JEALOUS, FOR THEY THINK  YOU ARE BETTER THAN THEM   DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME ON REVENGE THOSE WHO HURT YOU WILL EVENTUALLY  FACE THEIR OWN KARMA   NEVER TELL ANYONE YOUR PLANS SHOW THEM YOUR RESULTS   ONE GREAT LESSON I LEARNED FROM MY LIFE THERE IS NO MARKET FOR YOUR EMOTIONS SO NEVER ADVERTISE YOUR FEELINGS JUST SHOW YOUR ATTITUDE   DO NOT GIVE UP YOUR DAY WILL COME IT IS JUST A MATTER OF TIME   IF YOU ARE HELPING SOMEONE AND EXPECT SOMETHING IN RETURN YOU ARE DOING BUSINESS NOT KINDNESS   TRUST MEANS EVERYTHING ONCE IT IS  BROKEN SORRY MEANS NOTHING   ALWAYS REMEMBER YOUR PRESENT SITUATION IS NOT YOUR FINAL DESTINATION THE BEST IS YET TO COME   NEVER LEAVE A TRUE RELATION FOR A FEW FAULTS NOBODY IS CORRECT AT THE END AFFECTION IS ALWAYS GREATER THAN PERFECTION   DO NOT COME TO MY FUNERAL TO SHOW HOW MUCH YOU CARED ABOUT ME SHOW HOW MUCH YOU CARE ABOUT ME NOW WHILE I AM ALIVE   NEVER REPLAY WHEN YOU ARE ANGRY NEVER MAKE A PROMISE WHEN YOU ARE HAPPY NEVER MAKE A DECISION WHEN YOU ARE SAD   STOP EXPECTING LOYALTY FROM PEOPLE WHO CAN NOT EVEN GIVE YOU HONESTY   LIFE IS SHORT, TIME IS FAST NO REPLAY,  NO REWIND SO ENJOY EVERY MOMENT AS IT COMES   DO NOT GIVE UP THE BEGINNING IS  ALWAYS THE HARDEST   WHEN YOU WISH GOOD FOR OTHERS GOOD THINGS COME BACK TO YOU THIS IS THE LAW OF NATURE   DIFFICULTIES IN YOUR LIFE DO NOT COME TO DESTROY YOU BUT TO HELP YOU TO REALIZE YOUR HIDDEN POTENTIAL AND POWER   TURN YOUR ANGER INTO MOTIVATION AND YOUR MOTIVATION INTO SUCCESS.  
    • Ok lets reverse the relation , Daughter of some singh married into a Family of Hindu pandits ,but husband died , went to Pakistan and converted to islam.In that case would you have accepted her as Sikh?   The fact is she is daughter in law of Granthi so most probably she converted to Sikhism at the time of marriage.Now when she got widowed with three kids she had hardly any personal life left.Moreover I don't think his father  or Father in law thought of her re marriage.TBH there are hardly any sikh or Hindu men that marry a widow who is mother of three.So she may had found a Pakistani who was willing to accept her.Moreover she may had thought that she changed her religion for first marriage what's wrong if she did it for second time
    • Not sure on that, it's most likely out of our knowing until we merge with Waheguru.
×