Simran During Kirtan

[Thug Life]

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Simran During Kirtan what are your views on this??

i mean like doing a tukh of bani then busting into simran and breaking up the shabad?

[daughter of dasam pitha]

hummm

i'v bin thinkin bout that qwite few tyms jus neva gta chance to ask

personly i dnt fink it shud be done!

but les wait n ere sangats view on dis!

[jassa]

its akjs work as far as i know ... may be wrong ...

telling my personal experiance ... i am not much with akj ... but few friends always take me with them ... and i enjoy there kirten a lot ... more then in gurudwaras .... most of time while listenin kirten my mind leaves that place and and thoughts of shasters gatka friends gym games study etc come in my mind ... and as they perform raag at almost same volume ... i most of time realise that i was not mentaly present there when they finish the shabad ....

and i think this happens to most sitting in gurudwara ... so when the start simren in shabad its call that brings me back mentaly in gurudwara ....

what i think is its all about anand .... if u get anand doing it you should do it .... if it causes disturbance then u shouldnt ....

maffi

[Nihung Vikramdeep Singh]

its ooooooooooooook but when people start saying waheguru like chickens its more of a distraction that a medium for union with god.

[jassa]

now i remember this was one reason why kokke sikhs were declared non sikhs by akal takhth ... isnt it

[Guest Papi]

its ooooooooooooook but when people start saying waheguru like chickens its more of a distraction that a medium for union with god.

lol way to say it straight up