Question About The Rehat Maryada?

[The Khalsa Fauj]

I don't know why they left or if they even left. One Singh I forgot his name said that he went to Gurbachan Singh and he said that Akaal Takht maryada is the real Panthic maryada and that taksal maryada is only for the dera. So there you go. If I come across his name again. I will tell you.

[Gupt daasan daas]

do i care wat he said?

how is it panthic maryada if akj and taksal are not with it?

so u made ure own panth in ure mind now?

bhula chuka maf

[International Akaali]

the panthik parvan reyat maryada is the akal takht one. why arent akj and taksali's not with it? is it because they think there only right and they wont give up there Ankhar. I could get a bunch of people and say we believe this and make our own maryada. Then we'll say no this maryada is right not the akal takht or taksal one is right. This AKAL TAKHT maryada is for the somuchi sikh panth. Not for just indivduals who think it is right. No matter if you think it is wrong you are supposed to agree with it. You can keep everything to yourself. A lot of study and khoj has been taken to make this maryada. People like giani dit singh, proffeser Gurmukh singh musafur, bhai khan singh nabha and other great scholars made this. They studied this it wasn't mader by stories passed on by other people to see what is right or wrong.

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

[Gupt daasan daas]

actually no r singh

y dont u go and get ure fact straight

bhai sahib and sant je left because sgpc marada has to many stupid things

read it and ull find out

stuff like not full nitnem

stuff like not doing akhand paat with proper maryada

and r u saying sant je and bhai sahib had hankaar?

who has done more for the panth

akj and taksal or sgpc?

who gave shaheedi

weere was badal and tohra during shaheedi time

as for akal takht maryada, if u read damdami taksal maryada akal takht has ceritifid too

ill check again, but im pretty sure, like 99.9 percent sur thas wat i read when i saw it

a PANTHIC maryada is where veyone agrees

tha has been made yet

when it will im sure everyone will follow it

bhula chuka maf

[International Akaali]

actually no r singh

y dont u go and get ure fact straight

bhai sahib and sant je left because sgpc marada has to many stupid things

read it and ull find out

stuff like not full nitnem

stuff like not doing akhand paat with proper maryada

and r u saying sant je and bhai sahib had hankaar?

who has done more for the panth

akj and taksal or sgpc?

who gave shaheedi

weere was badal and tohra during shaheedi time

as for akal takht maryada, if u read damdami taksal maryada akal takht has ceritifid too

ill check again, but im pretty sure, like 99.9 percent sur thas wat i read when i saw it

a PANTHIC maryada is where veyone agrees

tha has been made yet

when it will im sure everyone will follow it

bhula chuka maf

113741[/snapback]

HAHAHA... IM sorry to tell you but SGPC DID NOT MAKE THE AKAL TAKHT REYAT MARYADA. Please read what i had written before the people who made the Akal takht maryada it was the sikh panth itself. Not SGPC. People like giani dit singh, proffeser Gurmukh singh musafur, bhai khan singh nabha and other great scholars made this. why did they leave thjey couldve solved things out. They couldve done whatever they believed. I understand they both take stand on a lot of things. Keski's raagmala etc. It doesnt permit anyone from not wearing keski. It doesn permit anyone for not reading raagmala. Im I think they just for there own stomach they wanted everything to go there way. Who agrred on the taksal maryada if you said it is a panthic maryada?

[Gupt daasan daas]

akal takht said IT IS ONE of the panthic maryadas out thee

meaning it aint agaisnt the panth

it aint like radhaswami or nothin

it has been approved by panth

and no ure wrong

if u read akal takht maryada, t has stuff that no jatha has

like rea dpart on how to hold akhand paats

it writes off everythin as brahmin vaad

tha means the enitre panth , all jathai, r wrong

and have been for manym any years

and like i SAID

THE PANTH DID NOT GET TOGETHER AND MAKE A PANTHIC MARYADA EVER

taksal and akj walked out

not agreegin with wat some of the singhs were saying

saying it was wrong

so until ALL jathai can come to one maryada, we will not have a panthic maryada

the '" panthic" maryada wud be going agaisnt more than half the panth

nanaksar, rara sahib , taksal, akj, nihangs, how is that a PANTHIC maryada then>?

bhula chuka maf

[kds1980]

waheguruji ka khalsa

waheguru ji fateh

i agree with khalsa fauj that all people should follow akal takhat maryada

i went to damdami taksal.com after reading a shabad about meat issue i was shocked that how are they misinterpretting gurbani

"If blood has stained your clothing you say your clothes have become impure. How can the thought of those who eat meat, drink blood and suck bones become pure?"

(SGGSJ Ang 140)

this from damdami taksal maryada now read the original shabad

Shalok, First Mehl:

jy rqu lgY kpVY jwmw hoie plIqu ] (140-9, mwJ, mÚ 1)

jay rat lagai kaprhai jaamaa ho-ay paleet.

If one's clothes are stained with blood, the garment becomes polluted.

jo rqu pIvih mwxsw iqn ikau inrmlu cIqu ] (140-10, mwJ, mÚ 1)

jo rat peeveh maansaa tin ki-o nirmal cheet.

Those who suck the blood of human beings-how can their consciousness be pure?

nwnk nwau Kudwie kw idil hCY muiK lyhu ] (140-10, mwJ, mÚ 1)

naanak naa-o khudaa-ay kaa dil hachhai mukh layho.

O Nanak, chant the Name of God, with heart-felt devotion.

Avir idvwjy dunI ky JUTy Aml kryhu ]1] (140-11, mwJ, mÚ 1)

avar divaajay dunee kay jhoothay amal karayhu. ||1||

Everything else is just a pompous worldly show, and the practice of false deeds. ||1||

no where the it is written in shabad that the person the thoughts of people

who drink blood eat meat or suck blood become impure.i also read punjabi translation of this shabd nowhere the shabad is dealing with this issue.to prove their point they are misinterpretting gurbani.this is mahapaap.i am not starting meat debate i just want to know the views of supporters of taksali maryada about this

my opinion is that these maryadas should be banned and only akal takhat maryada

should be followed.if this is not done then i think that in 100 years there will be 100

more maryadas of sants.

bhul chuk maaf

[Gupt daasan daas]

how has taksal misnterpeed the shabad

bhula chuka maf

[Taksali Singh]

To say Damdami Taksal, the school set by Satguroo Sree Guroo Gobind Singh Jee Maahaaraaj, has Misinterpreted Gurbaanee is absurd.

Think before you speak/type people....

When it comes to Baanee Taksal are on the top of the list...everyone knows that, but not everyone can handle it...

WJKKWJKP!

[The Khalsa Fauj]

To say Damdami Taksal, the school set by Satguroo Sree Guroo Gobind Singh Jee Maahaaraaj, has Misinterpreted Gurbaanee is absurd.

Think before you speak/type people....

When it comes to Baanee Taksal are on the top of the list...everyone knows that, but not everyone can handle it...

WJKKWJKP!

114340[/snapback]

Keep on dreaming! :wub: